Public educator selection · preserve first work before criteria or later sources. These pages are public; record prior access.

D-first-2 · teacher componentYear 1 Science · T2 W11–12 · Assessment / Components / D first 2

Complete held source: Original fiction. A broad paper ticket rests touching a drawn station-goal boundary and is not wholly inside it. The written rule says “reach the station” and does not say whether boundary touching counts. A child-character dictates, “Could we say whether touching counts before the next turn?” A helper writes these exact words. No next turn or other player’s reply is supplied.

Exact own prompt: What has the child-character communicated, and what did the helper do?

Descriptive criterion: Retains child-character question and helper exact recording; not an actual trial, player reply or the respondent’s observed performance.

Worked possibility, after own evidence: The child-character asked about deciding boundary touching before the next turn. The helper wrote the same words; no next turn is supplied.

Complete unrelated next account · A dictated request for a helper

Full source: Original unrelated fiction. A child-character asks “Could you read this picture rule aloud?” A helper writes those exact words. No reading, answer or game trial has yet happened.

Own invitation: What has each person done, and what remains unperformed?

Teach: Read the exact request once neutrally. Let the learner identify child-character ownership and helper recording. Distinguish asking, writing and actually reading rather than treating a request as completed help.

Observe: Request belongs to child-character; helper has recorded it only; reading/reply/game use absent.

Record the first exact evidence before help. A later source requires an actually recorded separate teaching opportunity. Source reasoning does not award an unperformed procedure or observation. Declined/not offered/not elicited/selected relation not shown remain distinct. This is not an official band or an annual grade.